Why I'm Never Going Back to Penny Arcade Expo (www.wired.com)
This is the second article I've read regarding this topic in the last three days. I'm not exactly sure what exactly is going on here, but I know that their response seemed pretty halfhearted to me. In particular, this bit twanged my "don't say that. don't say that EVER." nerve
So let me start by saying I like the Dickwolves strip. I think it’s a strong comic and I still think the joke is funny. Would we make that strip today? Knowing what we know now and seeing how it hurt people, no.
To me, this reads "I like the strip, but I regret getting in trouble for writing it." The logical decision here is to say "I'm sorry. No more rape jokes." When this all went down, that's not exactly how things got handled, as they elaborate.
I absolutely regret everything we did after that comic. I regret the follow up strip, I regret making the merchandise, I regret pulling the merchandise and I regret being such an asshole on twitter to people who were upset. I don’t think any of those things were good ideas. If we had just stopped with the strip and moved on, the Dickwolf never would have become what it is today. Which is a joke at the expense of rape victims or a symbol of the dismissal of people who have suffered a sexual assault.
Because of the aforementioned actions, fervor built up around the idea of dickwolves. Now, it seems that anyone who criticizes Penny Arcade or the way the situation was handled in a quasi-public forum gets accosted by the nerd-army with rape and death threats.
So, I have to wonder: Is it something about Penny Arcade? Is it youthful ignorance of societal norms and expected behavior? Are videogame nerds (collectively) assholes? What does it say about me that I laughed when I read that strip the first time round and that I wish I had a fruitfucker poster for my house?
I've read a couple of those articles too. Here are my convoluted thoughts.
It's really really really hard to recognize your own position of privilege. I'm going to use privilege and power pretty much interchangeably.
If you don't know what I'm talking about with privilege, read this classic article about white privilege: http://www.amptoons.com/blog/files/mcintosh.html
We all have privilege to differing degrees because of factors not entirely within our control such as race, socio-economic status, ability, business acumen, sexuality, gender, and a bunch of different factors.
I'm white and thus have some privilege. I've walked into an innercity, predominently black school on library business and been waived past security measures. The black father behind me bringing a forgotten lunch (who looked like he belonged more than me) went through the metal detectors and an extended questioning to get into the school.
I don't have power/privilege because of my gender. My brother and I lived in the same dorm years apart. I was routinely harassed by guys in cars and on foot at a certain intersection near that dorm. There were times at night it wasn't safe for me to walk alone. They actually had a safety patrol so I didn't have to. My brother never had this issue. However because of my sexuality, I have the privilege of talking about my life partner and people assume the correct gender.
We all have differing levels of privilege. It varies from situation to situation.
The Penny Arcade guys were bullied growing up. There they lacked the power because of (I don't know but guessing) lack of social acumen and athletic ability (or whatever, just going with the two most common). In some ways, they still see themselves as victims. Many of their fans likely (again going with stereotypes and typical social patterns) were similarly bullied as children/young adults. And all the fanboys who rally around the dickwolves also still see themselves as victims, but this time they can fight back.
No one ever sees themselves as the bully. We tend to focus on our lack of privilege, not our actual power. This is why you see a superstar/athlete/tycoon crying about how "mean" the media is to them. And why the Penny Arcade creators who wield incredible power in their corner of the universe can utterly fail to see how they are now the bully. How they and their fans can still cry "oppression" and "free speech".
You laughed at the joke in that context. That doesn't make you a bad person. Penny Arcade made the joke becuase they have never been that type of victim. They've never had to call a safety patrol because they were afraid to walk across campus. And they never consoled a friend who was raped on the anniversary of that rape. That makes them thoughtless, but not bad people. When this was pointed out to them, they should have done a mea culpa and ended it. It was their response they propelled them into the stratosphere of douchery.
No one is saying they don't have the freedom of speech to write these things, but maybe they need to think about it a bit harder. And they need to recognize that they are now in the position of power. As one of the former bullied, they should be more likely to take the side of the bullied. But we all know that isn't how the world usually works.
I am more concerned about the time they actively covered up a sexual assault on one of their volunteers. In the links here: http://elizabethsampat.com/quit-fucking-going-to-pax-already-what-is-wrong-with-you/ (elizabethsampat.com)
I'm afraid the "bullied young men turn to bullying online" is so common that it is frustrating and almost dull. Relevant: Weev and the cult of angry young men. http://www.theverge.com/2013/9/12/4693710/the-end-of-kindness-weev-and-the-cult-of-the-angry-young-man (www.theverge.com)
The better question is how do we raise the next generation to be more empathetic and compassionate people. Becuase I've written off anyone over the age of 12 by this point.
Not every day you get to meet the executive director of a major regulatory body. This guy. (www.ema.europa.eu)
Hey, I now understand why some of my friends and loved ones are gay - they were abused and didn't spend enough time with their father.
Fortunately this helpful children's book explains it all.
http://awfullibrarybooks.net/gayness-explained/ (awfullibrarybooks.net)
(FYI That is a librarian blog that highlights the worst books that are still in library collections and really need weeded.)
first I have to convince someone that yes, it is possible, to felt using a front-load washing machine. (knitting.about.com)
So when this happened I initially set up an appointment with Sears, which I thought was for this afternoon. It was set up for next week on Thursday. Well, we need it done before then, so I tried to have them come earlier. No dice.
I googled washer repair, and davetheapplianceguy.com (davetheapplianceguy.com). I called him and described the problem (it sounds like the motor is still spinning, but something broke in the linkage or transmission, since the basket doesn't spin). He immediately said, it sounds like the motor shaft linkage, and that it breaks all the time. He said replacement parts are ~$20 at an appliance store, and if it didn't work, I should give him a call.
Now I kinda just want to track him down and give him a case of beer.
I did run home at lunch and try to figure out if his solution would fix it, but I got to the point where I realized I was about to make a much larger mess than I was prepared for during a lunch hour. I'll try again later, but the more I think about it the more I think he's right.
In short, for any home appliance repair, Elizabeth and I will always use this guy from now on.
I turned my washing machine over topsy turvy, and its totally the part that Dave the Appliance Guy said. I can order a replacement at appliancepartspros.com (appliancepartspros.com). And, i can follow this video:
http://applianceass...sults.php?id=12101 (applianceassistant.com)
And repair it! This is something i can totally handle.
in short, idkfa, if you have home appliance issues, lets you and me try and fix it with the applianceassistant.com (applianceassistant.com) and appliancepartspros.com (appliancepartspros.com). If we can't, we'll totally use the davetheapplianceguy.com (davetheapplianceguy.com)! I want to help you save the moolah.
(edit: added hyperlinks)
So Orson Scott Card. I love the Ender's Game books. Love, love, love. I've read a bunch of his other stuff that isn't too obviously an allegory for Mormon theology. (Worthing Saga is great even if it is barely disguised Mormon theology). And I've been looking forward to the moives for YEARS. Yes he doesn't support gay marriage, but so do a lot of people. Maybe I can still see it and then make a donation to the Pride Foundation and that will equal it out? Isn't it censorship to avoid a writer's works because I don't like their moral views? Of course I'm getting the non-profit I'm on the board of to switch away from GoDaddy registration because of their stance on SOPA and their misogynistic advertising. So am I just making excuses because I really want to see this movie?
Skip Ender's Game boycott page: http://skipendersgame.com/ (skipendersgame.com)
NYT article on the controversy: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/21/opinion/sunday/the-enders-game-boycott.html?_r=0 (www.nytimes.com)
Also Orson Scott Card is crazy in so many more amusing ways. He thinks Obama is using urban gangs as a personal army so he can stay in power as some sort of dictator. http://www.slate.com/blogs/weigel/2013/08/14/orson_scott_card_worries_about_obama_turning_urban_gangs_into_his_personal.html (www.slate.com)
But historically genius creators have often been crazy. And I really want to see the movie. Sigh. What should a socially conscious geek girl do?
As idkfa's resident gay authority (by virtue of time served in these forums, thankyouverymuch), I hereby grant you movie visitation rights free of guilt. Also, you can drink all the Russian vodka you like. You can even watch the olympics if you want. I mean, I don't know who watches the winter olympics, but still.
Here's the thing: I have it on good authority that Lion's Gate employed, in the making of the Ender's Game movie, male hair and makeup artists and female carpenters and lighting techs, so ultimately your ticket purchase is going to support LGBT concerns. In fact, I would guess that the total percentage of your dollar going to LGBT individuals, not to mention straight-identified allies and ardent supporters, far surpasses the amount going into OSC's piggybank.
If I had to support the social agendas of every person involved with the creation of everything I consume, I would probably die, because I couldn't consume anything. Or die from the craziness of researching all their social opinions.
This all of course ignores that, assuming you didn't steal the book, you have already supported Card's craziness in some small way already.
Anyway, you have permission to see it! There are more important things to boycott or worry over than this.
As Robbie pointed out, by tenure he is the resident gay authority, so I defer to his position (wait. Can gays talk about positions in public? I digress...).
Since I've got a higher post count, I'm not sure what that makes me. I don't know the full idkfa user population, but we seem to have an atypically large "gay nerd" ratio around these parts. Well played, Josh.
Regardless, I agree. I'm "boycotting" Stoli, but only because I already preferred the cheaper Texan vodka made by Titos. I certainly don't think someone should avoid watching Ender's Game because of Orson Scott Card's insanity. I might not pay to see him speak, and I certainly wouldn't wait in line for his autograph, but the flick is mostly about feeding the machine of "Hollywood", which has arguably been pretty good to the gays as far as employment and support goes.
However, I will say this: fuck Chick-Fil-A, even if I do love their waffle fries. Never. Again. Also, Hobby Lobby with their religiously based protests of the health care modifications.
I was talking about a few positions with a gay last night, if you know what I'm saying. BOO-YA
But how is Chick-fil-A any different? Every cashier at the one close to the theatre I'm working at currently is flamboyantly homosexual. And their new salads are pretty legit. The last big Chick-fil-A boycott actually drove sales and they had a record setting year.
There has to be a better way to send a message and campaign for these things. There's nothing inherently anti-gay about fast food chicken or movies based on sci-fi young adult novels, so let's leave them alone. Boycotting stupid things connected to bigots or papering facebook with petitions and hash tagged cover photos isn't helping gay couples get married in Wyoming (the "land of equality") or adopt kids in Alabama. Complaining about Russian branded vodka isn't stopping gay kids from killing themselves. Better to send that effort, energy, and money to things like community LGBT centers or political campaigns.
I think there could be two very different versions of boycotting going on here. There's staunch, "line in the sand" style activism. This is driving halfway across town to shop at the gay-friendly second-hand bookstore while you eat your imported skyre. I'll dub this Dan Savage Style. There's also "soccer mom" boycotting, where you try to avoid Target and Chick-Fil-A, unless your kids REALLLY want that awful sandwich with only chicken, bread, and a pickle.
In the so-called free market the US uses for business interaction, I'm a much larger fan of the latter style of boycotting. Any PR is generally good PR, even if you're associated with race riots and mass lynching (see: Tulsa). Name recognition is more important than why your name is recognized. Chick-Fil-A saw a huge spike in sales in my hometown because all the backwater rednecks who generally survive on Arby's Cups-o-Cheddar thought they needed to defend their Sky Jesus by eating more chicken, so they descended in droves with greasy wads of cash in hand.
Meanwhile, if you just go about your business, avoiding companies you know to be vehemently against your views, you're doing a bit of good, you're not expending unnecessary energy, and you're not that guy who never gets invited to dinner because of the forty minute speech about the injustices committed against mother earth to deliver that crystal decanter. (Aside: I have been that guy. I probably am that guy still. See: Zero Dark Thirty).
All that aside: if you're the CEO of a company, maybe you follow the CostCo model. Don't be a dick, keep your trap shut about social issues that don't concern you, and sell me my M&Ms by the cargo plane.
I like that delineation of types of boycotting. I was raised on the second "avoid as much as possible" style. My parents can't stand how Wal-mart treats their labor and what they do to small towns so we didn't shop at wally world if avoidable at all. When I first moved to Alaska and had not yet discovered that Freddy's had everything in the world (because grocery stores in Kansas weren't like that) and Target hadn't been opened I went to Wal-mart for an ironing board but not since. But as Mike said, I have that ecnomic choice. And I make it. Basically a thousand small choices do more good than that guy who screams at the top of his lungs.
I am on the board of a non-profit and I've convinced them to move our website domain away from GoDaddy because I hate their misogynistic advertisments and their stand on SOPA. There are a thousand other little things too I suppose.
So I will go and see it, and thank you all for making me feel better about it. And I'll still make an LGBTQ friendly charity donation.
And perhaps more importantly for the cause, the library is hosting an LGBTQ teen club (easier for some kids to come to than the one at their school) and there is a guy who is going from library location to location blasting and threatening staff members with profanity about the club (apparently we're trying to convert kids to be gay, sigh). He's also been on our facebook page, but we deleted it. He's one more tirade away from a year ban, and we're ready for him. In my opinion, offering a safe space for the next generation and protecting them from idiots as much as possible is more important than which movie I see.
tl;dr - there is no Chick-Fil-A in Alaska.
But seriously, they had a strong presence on campus at Texas A&M, particularly in the middle of a huge dorm complex. They trucked out troughs of waffle fries for the eager masses, myself included. I didn't know about their politics. I just wanted waffle fries dipped in sweet and sour sauce.
Kristens roommate reached into her waffle-pouch (sic) and discovered a deep fried hairball, which quickly killed the girls collective taste for Chick-Fil-A. I admit I continued to frequent the venue as long as I lived on that side of campus.
I try to think about the societal impact of engaging a business practice I disagree with. The Wal-Mart model is not a society I want to live in, so it is one I don't encourage. I don't want my own employer to use me as dispensable labor to be abused, no matter my education or qualifications, so I shouldn't reward businesses that do. The same applies to civil rights.
Then again, my family has the income that make those choices easier, so I can't really blame someone for choosing a cheaper option for the same product.
I like the Costco model, and I think it stems from two important aspects - the owner(s) not being beholden to shareholders, and not being dicks. If I hadn't an aptitude for school, I would be lucky to have a job at Costco where they try to pay a living wage, offer benefits and upward mobility.
Chick-Fil-A and Hobby Lobby, are doing Christian business the wrong way.
Doing it right: Braum's dairy and grocery. They own all parts of the dairy to maintain freshness. They won't ship more than the 300 miles away (or half a day's drive) to maintain the freshness and because their truck drivers can drive to the location and back in one day and still spend the night with their family. So the only truck drivers who never have to spend a night away from home.
That's family values I can get behind. And we ate ice cream there multiple times while in Oklahoma last week.
Two caribou, opening day, at my family's cabin. Spotted and shot the first in the morning (my first Caribou), then the second later in the afternoon. Surprised that I didn't get squeamish watching/helping the animals being prepared. Celebrated by watching episodes of Firefly and drinking Crown Royal Special Reserve. Good weekend overall.