I'd agree with you both. I thought the show overall was a good show. I'm not sure what it was in the beginning though, I just wasn't into it right away. It very much could have been me, but there was a certain point where I got invested into it (I know those because I put my Words With Friends away :P) I do remember the Try This on For Size as being good.

Also Erik brought up a point about not watching the replay. Are the shows taped to go back over? I think that's an excellent idea. I know I saw someone using a iphone to record in the back for a little while, but I don't know if that'd be good enough for the viewing. I also think the one's Erik were in were some of the highlights of the show. I'm pretty sure every girl there wanted to pick him up and take him home as a pet :P

As for the Freudian slip one, it did seem like it was going nowhere and it was probably for the best that it ended. I'm just saying you guys have done it better before. Oh, while I'm giving out constructive criticism, I think as the narrator, John you should have explained what the 1-3-5 meant. I spent most of that time counting syllables to see if that was what it meant.